*Spoiler alert* the ending of Emilia Perez will be discussed.
Oscar nominations and the Golden Globe winners of 2025, the most controversial film on both of these lists is Emilia Perez. On social media we see many people having issues with the songs in this musical. There have been many jokes around two specific songs, La Vaginoplastia and Todo y Nada. On the other side of the conversation about this musical, we have people discussing the social issues with this film. Many Mexicanos and trans people have brought up issues with the writing and directing, pointing out many problematic themes and dialogue. I will explore the social issues people bring up with this film, but first I will discuss the actual filmmaking of this musical.
The actual overall plot of this film had some potential. Zoe Saldana plays Rita, an intelligent Mexican lawyer. She is employed by Manitas del Monte, true name Emilia Perez, a drug kingpin. Rita is hired to help Perez find a doctor to help with surgeries for her transition. Emilia undergoes a sex change through many surgeries and legally becomes Emilia Perez. Rita moved Emilia’s family to Switzerland to keep them safe, but later Emilia asks for them to move to Mexico with her. She acts as a distant cousin of Manitas’ to both her ex wife and her sons. Emilia Perez creates a non-government organization designed to help families find their missing relatives. Emilia’s ex wife, Jessi, reveals that she is getting married to someone new. Emilia is angry and escalating events lead to a shootout. In the end, Jessi, her fiance, and Emilia all die in a car accident.
While this plot could have led to a film that analyzes real and pressing issues in today’s world, the execution was very poor. The pacing of this film felt off. We spend maybe 40 minutes with the lawyer while she figures out the transition. Within this 40 minutes so much happens that remains unexplained. And much of this section felt surreal, many of the sets used felt extra fake, and they seem to have tried to develop Rita’s character when she gets plastic surgery herself. At least, I think she got plastic surgery. This section of the film was so fast and confusing I am not 100% sure what happens. They spend relatively no time on the transition for Emilia or for her family. And the rest of the film is spent with Emilia, with maybe one small moment where she admits to the wrongdoings of her past. The film asks you to forgive Emilia for all the wrong she has done as a drug kingpin just because she transitioned and started the NGO. They spend no time on a redemption arc for Emilia, and they skip over the harm she has caused.
The characters had interesting concepts going in, but they are not fleshed out characters with arcs. Rita is just a yes-man who does not change throughout the film. She becomes a lawyer for a different bad guy and gains a friend. But nothing in her moral code, her identity, or personality changes by the end of the film. As mentioned before, Emilia is just forgiven by the film for all the bad she has done. She does change literally, doing gender affirming surgery, but we are given no arc for her personality change. She is just suddenly good. Jessi is given no character to begin with, so there is no arc for her. By the end of the film, even as many of the characters died, I felt nothing for them. I was given less than a reason to. Many of these characters are bad people that are given no arc or reason for what they do to grasp as an audience.
The filmmaking itself felt cheap. Perhaps this was on purpose, as the director has banished much criticism by calling himself a misunderstood artist. The indoor sets seem very fake, especially the hospitals and the courtroom. And the sets of Mexican streets lean into the idea that Mexico is underdeveloped and dirty. The lighting seems overdramatic without meaning. The best aspect of this film is the cinematography which is grand and interesting. They use a lot of cinematic and Oscar worthy shots, like a frame within a frame, which they use a lot. However, the use of these shots seem to have no meaning, it seems that they just wanted to use a cool shot.
Moving onto the music, which has been ceaselessly mocked on social media. I was hoping to see some songs that were better than the two I had seen on Instagram, but I was shocked to find that those two songs are some of the better musical numbers. Many of the numbers were just the characters speaking rhythmically and quietly. Every time I have told someone about this, they say that it sounds like they are trying to do what Lin-Manuel Miranda does, but failing. This feels like a very true statement. If you are interested in hearing what I am talking about, listen to the song El Encuentro from this film. At the end of the day, the music in this film is bad.
Having established my opinions on the filmmaking I will briefly touch on the social issues with this film. I am not going to go into depth, if you are interested in learning more about this I would suggest the YouTube Video Emilia Pérez Is The Messiest Movie I’ve Ever Seen- and It Deserves All the Hate It’s Getting… by creator Salem Tovar. She is a Mexican American who dives into her culture’s reaction to this film. If you want to hear more from the side of the trans community, I would suggest the video The Racist Cisgender Nonsense of Emilia Perez by the creator Jessie Gender. A note on myself here, I am of Salvadoran descent and have some knowledge in this area. But I am not Mexican, so I cannot speak to this community fully. I am also a part of the LGBTQIA+ community, but I am not a part of the trans community, so I can only speak on so much here.
Much of the controversy of this film surrounds the director. Jacques Audiard is the writer/director for this film. You may have guessed from his name that he is not Latin-American, he is not even Spanish. He is french. Lots of the issues of the film stem from the fact that he wrote this script with no research, and he wrote the script originally in French and translated it into Spanish. (note that this is one of the reasons the music is so bad). Jacques Audiard claimed that he already knew enough about Mexico and did not need to do any research. Any writer or filmmaker would know that, no matter what, you always do a lot of research into your subject matter. Claiming that you know enough about a culture you are not a part of and then writing a script surrounding that culture led to many issues throughout this film.
Another issue many people have with this film is the casting of the main characters. While most of this story takes place in Mexico, with Mexican characters, 2 out of 3 of the main actresses were not Mexican. Zoe Saldana is a Dominican American who relearned Spanish for this role. She told the director that she is of Dominican accent, and that Spanish speakers who watch the film would be able to tell. In response, the director shoe-horned in one line in the script where Rita says she is from the Dominican but grew up in Mexico. One issue with this line is that it is so briefly mentioned, and late in the movie. The other main issue is that if Rita grew up in Mexico, she would have a Mexican accent. This one line does not fix the accent issue. The other, more widely criticized non-Mexican actor cast in this film is Selena Gomez. While Gomez is Mexican American, the community has turned against her in the past over her use of her heritage, and they have turned against her again. In the past she has refused to learn Spanish or meaningfully connect to Mexican culture, but she uses her heritage to make fun of Mexican people. In an episode of SNL she hosted, there is a clear example of this. When it comes to Emilia Perez, she again refused to learn Spanish or research well for this role. She claims she had no time, but she certainly had time to get better than she did. Because she refused to learn Spanish, a lot of her lines were half in Spanish and half in English. And the Spanish that she did speak was in a very bad American accent.
While this film took place in Mexico, and did this poorly, the main themes of this movie revolve around transgender issues. The title character, Emilia Perez, has a medical transition through the use of surgeries around 40 minutes into the film. These surgeries are orchestrated by Rita and a doctor, who are both cisgender, and Rita argues on behalf of Emilia and the trans community. Some issues were brought up in the community about not having Emilia be part of her own transition. Much of the community found issues with the fact that Emilia got all of her surgeries at the same time, which no doctor would do. This moment shows perfectly how little research was done for this film. The film also treats Emilia’s transitions as a full clean slate and a full personality switch. Just because she medically transitioned, she is now a good person.
If you are interested in learning more about this, I would suggest those videos linked before and doing more research on critics and what they have to say. This is just a small fraction of the issues in this film. I am not saying that it is impossible to enjoy this film, there are people who have. I am only speaking of my opinion here, feel free to make your own!

About the Author
My name is Roma Bickerton, and I am a sophomore studying Film and Television Production with a concentration in Directing and a minor and Political Science. I hope to direct feature films someday, but right now I am most interested in fight choreography. I hope to give a rundown of the most nominated films at this year’s Oscars and offer some of my opinions on them. I hope everyone also watches some of these films, but I know there is a lot of them, so maybe this blog can help prepare you to watch the Oscars!
Leave a Reply