Lily’s Library: When in Rome- Simple, Sweet, and Soothing

One of the main criticisms I have encountered regarding romantic-comedies and romance novels is: “That’s so cheesy. Why not read something with meaning?” To that I say, who says they do not have meaning, and no thank you. There is infinite time to read deep and philosophical books that alter the way you see the world, but right now, in a time of deep turmoil and seemingly no one liking each other, I feel content with sticking with my “simple” and “cheesy” romance novels. I think everybody who chooses to read anything should feel the same. All of this to say, When in Rome, by Sarah Adams is a darling smalltown love story that has companion novels that I will find a way to get my hands on very soon. Until then, let us discuss what I was obsessed with and what I think might have made the book a tab bit more believable.

     To begin, Sarah Adams won me over with having a main character that was enthralled with Audrey Hepburn and dreamed of finding her own Gregory Peck, enough said. However, I do find the writing of our main character, Amelia Rose, to be slightly outdated and falling into the category of what I deem “Disney-relatable characters.” Disney has recently had this habit of making their female leads dorky and at times incompetent, but ultimately figure out their problems and all is resolved within an hour and a half. Amelia falls into a similar category. While her complexity of being a famous singer who doesn’t necessarily long for fame is intriguing and introduces the reader to the complexities of being in the public, it seems as though Amelia gets herself into a lot of problems, has others fix them or they fix themselves, and all is right. Now, I can see how this might seem like I hate the character, which I certainly did not. There are so many cute moments throughout the story of Amelia experiencing small-town life and longing for lost relationship with her mom. She is a character that feels everything pretty deeply and wishes for a gentle love that she never experienced. I just find that Adams introduces too many problems that are easily solved. For example, Amelia and her mom. There is an arc the entire story of how Amelia’s mom is using her for money and doesn’t really care about her daughter. In the end, Amelia somehow discovers that her manger has been feeding her lies-this really comes out of thin air in my opinion-and calls her mom, apologizes, and they are suddenly best friends. I would have loved to see Amelia slowing gain her trust back in her mom, or even end the story with them on unsure terms seeing as broken trust is molded over time and won’t suddenly be healed by one phone call. It all happened too quickly for me.

     Now, Noah Walker, he is a different story. Let me begin by saying: I love a black-cat character that is reserved but loves with their whole being, just as much as the next person. However, I wish more authors would switch up their descriptors when choosing a defining characteristic for someone. If I see one more quiet character described as “frowning” I might cry. It makes the introverts seem as though they are having a tantrum all the time, not to mention that in a romance story frowning is not the most appealing description, at least not for me 24/7. Besides that point, I really enjoyed the way that Sarah Adams wrote Noah. She made him deeply invested in his family and taking care of others while being so endeared to his small town and not someone looking to leave it any time soon. He also owns a bakery and buys flowers from his sister’s shop so she doesn’t go out of business. Swoon. My favorite thing about the way Adams writes Noah has to be his ability to seem mellow but he is definitely freaking out inside when a very pretty woman stops in front of his house. All-in-all, our two lovebirds are polar opposites that are quite literally made for each other. Nothing else to say.

     In the end, not to beat a dead horse, but the biggest roadblock I came to when reading When in Rome was, again, the far too quick problem-solving scenes. Let me indulge for just one more second. So, seeing as Amelia is such a big star it is no surprise that the media wants to track her and nudge their way through her privacy. Inevitably that happens and a swarm of them are surrounding her and Noah one day. But, instead of the situation getting tense and building to a climax, all of a sudden her manager and security team show up and save the two! I mean… Now we ultimately learn that this is because her manager had called the press and arranged it all, but even the way that Amelia figures that fact out is far too quick. Maybe I am just too slow to realizations and can’t believe that I would ever personally come to such a conclusion so quickly. But also the pacing when reading is incredibly quick. It’s such a bummer because without this issue, I really think I would have given the book five stars. But for now, I shall be satisfied with my three star rating and the hope that the companion novels are slowed down a little bit.

One of the main criticisms I have encountered regarding romantic-comedies and romance novels is: “That’s so cheesy. Why not read something with meaning?” To that I say, who says they do not have meaning, and no thank you. There is infinite time to read deep and philosophical books that alter the way you see the world, but right now, in a time of deep turmoil and seemingly no one liking each other, I feel content with sticking with my “simple” and “cheesy” romance novels. I think everybody who chooses to read anything should feel the same. All of this to say, When in Rome, by Sarah Adams is a darling smalltown love story that has companion novels that I will find a way to get my hands on very soon. Until then, let us discuss what I was obsessed with and what I think might have made the book a tab bit more believable.

     To begin, Sarah Adams won me over with having a main character that was enthralled with Audrey Hepburn and dreamed of finding her own Gregory Peck, enough said. However, I do find the writing of our main character, Amelia Rose, to be slightly outdated and falling into the category of what I deem “Disney-relatable characters.” Disney has recently had this habit of making their female leads dorky and at times incompetent, but ultimately figure out their problems and all is resolved within an hour and a half. Amelia falls into a similar category. While her complexity of being a famous singer who doesn’t necessarily long for fame is intriguing and introduces the reader to the complexities of being in the public, it seems as though Amelia gets herself into a lot of problems, has others fix them or they fix themselves, and all is right. Now, I can see how this might seem like I hate the character, which I certainly did not. There are so many cute moments throughout the story of Amelia experiencing small-town life and longing for lost relationship with her mom. She is a character that feels everything pretty deeply and wishes for a gentle love that she never experienced. I just find that Adams introduces too many problems that are easily solved. For example, Amelia and her mom. There is an arc the entire story of how Amelia’s mom is using her for money and doesn’t really care about her daughter. In the end, Amelia somehow discovers that her manger has been feeding her lies-this really comes out of thin air in my opinion-and calls her mom, apologizes, and they are suddenly best friends. I would have loved to see Amelia slowing gain her trust back in her mom, or even end the story with them on unsure terms seeing as broken trust is molded over time and won’t suddenly be healed by one phone call. It all happened too quickly for me.

     Now, Noah Walker, he is a different story. Let me begin by saying: I love a black-cat character that is reserved but loves with their whole being, just as much as the next person. However, I wish more authors would switch up their descriptors when choosing a defining characteristic for someone. If I see one more quiet character described as “frowning” I might cry. It makes the introverts seem as though they are having a tantrum all the time, not to mention that in a romance story frowning is not the most appealing description, at least not for me 24/7. Besides that point, I really enjoyed the way that Sarah Adams wrote Noah. She made him deeply invested in his family and taking care of others while being so endeared to his small town and not someone looking to leave it any time soon. He also owns a bakery and buys flowers from his sister’s shop so she doesn’t go out of business. Swoon. My favorite thing about the way Adams writes Noah has to be his ability to seem mellow but he is definitely freaking out inside when a very pretty woman stops in front of his house. All-in-all, our two lovebirds are polar opposites that are quite literally made for each other. Nothing else to say.

     In the end, not to beat a dead horse, but the biggest roadblock I came to when reading When in Rome was, again, the far too quick problem-solving scenes. Let me indulge for just one more second. So, seeing as Amelia is such a big star it is no surprise that the media wants to track her and nudge their way through her privacy. Inevitably that happens and a swarm of them are surrounding her and Noah one day. But, instead of the situation getting tense and building to a climax, all of a sudden her manager and security team show up and save the two! I mean… Now we ultimately learn that this is because her manager had called the press and arranged it all, but even the way that Amelia figures that fact out is far too quick. Maybe I am just too slow to realizations and can’t believe that I would ever personally come to such a conclusion so quickly. But also the pacing when reading is incredibly quick. It’s such a bummer because without this issue, I really think I would have given the book five stars. But for now, I shall be satisfied with my three star rating and the hope that the companion novels are slowed down a little bit.

About the Author: Lily is a transfer student majoring in Political Science and minoring in History. During her spare time, she indulges in different cinematic, musical, and literary worlds she finds. Most often, Lily escapes from the seriousness of the world through fluffy romance and historical fiction. Check out her Goodreads page for frequent reading updates!

Link: https://www.goodreads.com/user/show/169235985-lily-lauritson

Leave a Reply

Create a website or blog at WordPress.com

Up ↑